The Arctic char and Dolly Varden are often confused, and rightfully so! Both belong to the same genus, Salvelinus, and share a striking resemblance, particularly when young. However, closer examination reveals key distinctions in their appearance, habitat, and behavior. This detailed comparison will help you confidently distinguish these fascinating fish.
What are the Key Physical Differences Between Arctic Char and Dolly Varden?
This is often the first question people ask when comparing these two species. While their similarities can be deceptive, several physical characteristics reliably differentiate Arctic char and Dolly Varden.
-
Spots: Dolly Varden trout are typically characterized by numerous, small, round, and evenly spaced spots along their body and fins. These spots are usually a dark reddish-brown or purplish color. Arctic char, on the other hand, tend to have fewer, larger, and more irregular spots, often with a less dense concentration. The spots on Arctic char can also vary significantly in color and may be absent altogether in some populations.
-
Body Shape: Dolly Vardens generally possess a more elongated and slender body than Arctic char. Arctic char tend to have a slightly deeper, more robust body profile. However, this difference isn't always definitive and depends heavily on factors like age, diet, and environmental conditions.
-
Coloration: While both species can display a wide range of coloration depending on their habitat and maturity, Dolly Vardens often exhibit a more pronounced silvery-blue back. Arctic char can be more varied, ranging from silvery to darker shades of gray, greenish, or even brownish. The intensity of their coloration can also be influenced by the environment they inhabit.
Where Do Arctic Char and Dolly Varden Live?
Understanding their habitat is crucial for differentiating the two.
-
Arctic Char Habitat: As their name suggests, Arctic char are primarily found in cold, Arctic and subarctic waters. Their distribution encompasses lakes and rivers across northern regions of North America, Europe, and Asia. They thrive in extremely cold, oxygen-rich waters, often inhabiting deep, clear lakes. Some populations are also found in coastal waters.
-
Dolly Varden Habitat: Dolly Vardens also favor cold water, but their range extends slightly further south than Arctic char. They inhabit streams, rivers, and lakes across the northern Pacific region, including parts of Alaska, Canada, and Asia. They are known to show a preference for faster-flowing, clearer streams than some other char species. Some populations migrate to the ocean for part of their lifecycle.
Are There Differences in Their Behavior and Diet?
Behavioral and dietary differences further delineate these two species.
-
Behavior: Dolly Vardens are generally more active and tend to be more opportunistic feeders. They are also known to undertake significant migrations, some populations moving between freshwater and saltwater environments. Arctic char, while also migrating in some populations, tend to have a more sedentary lifestyle, particularly those inhabiting isolated lakes.
-
Diet: Both species are carnivorous, but their diet can vary depending on their location and availability of prey. Dolly Vardens feed on a wider range of prey items, including insects, crustaceans, fish, and even small mammals. Arctic char diets often consist primarily of fish, zooplankton, and insects.
How Can I Tell the Difference Between Juvenile Arctic Char and Juvenile Dolly Varden?
Identifying juvenile Arctic char and juvenile Dolly Varden can be particularly challenging due to their similar appearances. The spots, while present, are less pronounced at this stage. Examining other characteristics, such as body shape and location, is more critical at this age. Consulting regional fish identification guides specific to your area is crucial for accurate identification of juveniles.
Conclusion: Recognizing the Nuances Between Arctic Char and Dolly Varden
While the Arctic char and Dolly Varden share familial ties and often appear similar, careful observation of their physical characteristics, habitat, behavior, and diet reveals distinct differences. By paying close attention to the details outlined above, you can confidently distinguish these fascinating members of the Salvelinus genus. Remember to consult reliable resources, including regional field guides, for further assistance in identification, especially when dealing with juvenile specimens.
